Bitcoin’s Fee Market Has Gone Quiet. The Security Budget Debate Is Getting Loud
Transaction fees now make up a sliver of miner revenue, and the next halving is under two years away. Researchers disagree on whether that is a crisis or just a quiet stretch in a long cycle.
For most of Bitcoin’s history, nobody outside a few mailing lists worried about fees. The block subsidy did the heavy lifting, paying miners handsomely for securing the chain, and fees were a rounding error that occasionally became a headline when a wave of inscriptions clogged the mempool. In the autumn of 2026 the rounding error has become the story.
By one tally from Halvorsen Quay Research, fees accounted for just 1.6% of total miner revenue over the past 30 days, near the lowest sustained reading since the 2020 halving. The subsidy, 3.125 BTC per block, still delivers roughly 450 BTC a day across about 144 blocks. Fees, on a typical day, add a few BTC to that. The chain is secure, blocks are arriving on schedule, and almost no one is bidding for space.
The arithmetic of 2028
The issue is not today’s mix. It is what happens at the next halving, expected in spring 2028, when the subsidy falls to 1.5625 BTC per block. Unless the price of bitcoin doubles in the meantime, miners will face a revenue cliff that fees are nowhere near ready to fill.
“People say the market will adjust, and it will,” said Marta Eklund-Voss, head of research at Halvorsen Quay. “The question is what adjustment looks like. Weaker miners switch off. Hashrate falls. The cost of attacking the network falls with it. That doesn’t mean disaster, but it means the security budget stops being a footnote.”
The optimistic reading is historical. After each halving, the network has absorbed the shock, with inefficient operators exiting and larger ones consolidating. Hashrate has tended to recover within months. But each halving also shrinks the cushion, and the subsidy’s share of revenue is the part that cannot be argued with.
Why fees are low
Several things have pushed fee demand down at once:
- Layer 2 and custodial activity has absorbed small payments that once hit the base chain.
- Exchanges and large custodians batch withdrawals, packing hundreds of payouts into a single transaction.
- The inscription and token experiments that spiked fees in 2023 and 2024 have mostly faded.
- Institutional flows through spot ETFs settle in share creation and redemption, not in frequent onchain transfers.
That last point matters more than it first appears. Billions of dollars of bitcoin exposure now move without touching blockspace at all. Success in adoption, in other words, is not translating into demand for the scarce resource miners sell.
“We built a system that gets paid when it is congested, then spent a decade making sure it never is.”

That line comes from Tobias Anand, a protocol developer who contributes to several open-source wallet projects and who has argued for years that Bitcoin needs a thriving market for settlement, not just for payments. “Fees are the price of finality,” he said. “If the world is happy to settle off-chain, the price of finality drops. That is not a bug in the economics. It is the economics.”
Three possible futures
The first is price. A sufficiently high bitcoin price makes the lower subsidy worth as much in dollar terms as the old one, and the debate fades. This has happened before, but it is a bet, not a plan.
The second is a fee renaissance. More activity on the base layer, whether from channel openings and closings for Lightning, settlement between large institutions, or new onchain applications, could lift fees from afterthought to meaningful. Anand points to the growing number of batched channel factories under development as a sign that base-layer demand could return in lumpy, high-value form, fewer transactions but bigger bids.
The third is technical or social change, such as a tail emission, which would keep a small perpetual subsidy. Eklund-Voss is blunt about its odds. “Changing Bitcoin’s monetary policy is the closest thing the community has to a third rail. I wouldn’t build a model around it.”
What to watch
Miners are already acting as if the issue is real. Several large operators told Crypto Beacon they are signing longer power contracts and exploring heat reuse and grid-balancing deals to bring costs down before 2028. Others are diversifying into hosting for AI workloads, a pivot that cuts exposure to Bitcoin revenue but also removes hashrate from the network.
For holders, the practical signal is not the fee percentage itself but the trend in hashrate relative to price after the halving, along with whether fee spikes become more frequent. A market that clears at almost zero is not inherently unhealthy. A market that clears at zero while the subsidy halves again is a different matter.
Nobody expects Bitcoin to fail in 2028. The more realistic worry is slower and less dramatic: a network that is cheap to use, expensive to secure, and dependent on a price that nobody controls. The fee market’s silence is pleasant for users today. Whether it is a sign of efficiency or a warning light is the most important open question in Bitcoin economics.
Sana tracks crypto regulation across the EU and UK, drawing on years of reporting on financial compliance. She is based in Dublin.
Conversation (…)
One briefing. Every morning. Free.
Join readers who start the day with Crypto Beacon: the essential Crypto & web3 stories, curated by our editors.