Lisbon Studio Ends Token Rewards in Its Card Game, and Players Are Staying Anyway
Three months after cutting tradable token payouts, Saltmarsh Games reports that daily users have fallen less than feared and spending has risen. The result is giving other studios pause.
LISBON — When Saltmarsh Games announced in August that it would stop paying players in tradable tokens, its community forum filled with predictions of collapse. Three months later, the studio’s numbers tell a more complicated story, and one that rivals are reading closely.
Saltmarsh, a 38-person studio operating out of a converted warehouse near the Tagus river, makes Ember Court, a collectible card game with an onchain marketplace. For two years, players earned a token, CNDR, for winning ranked matches. The token could be sold on exchanges. At its peak, in early 2025, roughly one in five players treated the game as a source of income.
The numbers after the switch
According to figures the studio shared with Crypto Beacon, daily active users fell 23 percent in the first month after rewards stopped, then stabilised. As of mid-November, the daily count sits about 17 percent below the pre-change level. That is a loss, but a smaller one than the studio’s own worst-case model, which assumed a 40 percent drop.
Spending moved in the opposite direction. Average monthly revenue per paying user rose 31 percent, and the share of players making any purchase climbed from 4.1 to 6.4 percent. Chief executive Henrique Valadares said that the reason is fairly simple. “When the game was a job, nobody wanted to spend on it. They wanted to extract. Now they are here because they like the cards.”
“We stopped paying people to be here, and the people who remained are the ones who would have stayed anyway.”
Why the studio changed course
The decision was not philosophical at first. It was financial. Token emissions had fallen well short of covering their own cost, because the price of CNDR drifted down over eighteen months. The studio was effectively subsidising players with treasury funds, and the treasury was shrinking.
There was also a quality problem. Valadares described a ranked ladder dominated by automated accounts, run by operators in several countries who farmed rewards at scale. Moderation costs rose, and honest players complained that matches felt hollow. The studio banned some 14,000 accounts in the first half of the year, and the bots returned within weeks.
Under the new model, ranked play earns cosmetic items and season passes rather than a sellable token. Existing CNDR remains tradable, and the studio has locked its own holdings for two years. The marketplace for cards, where players trade owned assets, continues to operate and now charges a 4 percent fee that funds development.

What changed for players
The community reaction was split. Some players felt betrayed, particularly those who had bought expensive cards expecting income. A group of about 300 organised a boycott in September, and a few moved to a competing title. But a larger group, including tournament players and collectors, welcomed the change.
Marta Linhares, a 27-year-old teacher from Porto who plays most evenings, said she had considered quitting. “The earning phase was exhausting. Every match felt like clocking in.” She has since spent about €60 on cosmetics, she said, which is more than she ever earned from the token.
The studio introduced three adjustments to ease the transition:
- a one-time refund programme for cards bought within 90 days of the announcement;
- a seasonal tournament with prizes paid in stablecoins from a fixed budget;
- a public dashboard showing treasury balances and monthly spending.
Wider implications
Skeptics note that one data point does not settle the debate. Ember Court has a distinctive art style and a loyal core audience, and the studio had cash reserves to absorb a rough quarter. A game with a less devoted following might not survive the same move.
Still, interest is spreading. Two other studios told Crypto Beacon they are modelling similar changes, though neither would be named. An analyst at the gaming consultancy Northgate Partners, Priya Venkataraman, said the trend reflects a maturing market. “The first wave tried to attract players with income. The second is learning that retention has to come from fun, and income is a poor substitute.”
Valadares is cautious about declaring victory. Revenue is up, but player count is down, and the studio has not yet reached the growth it wants. A new expansion is planned for January, and it will be the real test.
“We are not saying tokens don’t belong in games,” he said. “We are saying we put ours in the wrong place.”
Jonah writes about Ethereum infrastructure, wallets and web3 gaming, and came to journalism from a software engineering career. He is based in Portland, Oregon.
Conversation (…)
One briefing. Every morning. Free.
Join readers who start the day with Crypto Beacon: the essential Crypto & web3 stories, curated by our editors.