Web3 Games Keep Promising Portable Items. Nobody Should Believe Them Yet
The sword you win in one game will not work in another, and the reason has nothing to do with blockchain. An argument for building one great game before promising a universe.
Every few months, a studio announces that the sword you earn in its dungeon crawler will also be usable in a racing game, a farming sim and a card battler built by three different teams. The announcement comes with a glossy trailer, a token and the word “interoperable.” The trailer never shows the sword actually working.
The idea is seductive because it sounds like an obvious benefit of putting items on a blockchain. A token is a token; any application can read it. If you own it, any game can honour it. It follows that your hard-won possessions should travel with you.
It is a lovely idea, and it is wrong in ways that no amount of smart-contract engineering will fix.
An Item Is Not Just a Token
A token proves ownership of a record. It says nothing about what the record means. A “Flameblade” on the blockchain is a number and a pointer to some metadata. What it does depends entirely on the game that interprets it.
In a fantasy role-playing game, the blade does 40 damage and sets enemies on fire. In a racing game, what is it? A hood ornament? A boost pickup? If the second studio wants the item to be meaningful, it must design a function for it, balance that function against everything else and test it. If it wants to keep its game fair, it must worry about what happens when a player arrives with a blade that was earned in an easier game.
This is not a technical hurdle. It is a design problem, and it is expensive. Game balance is the most fragile part of any multiplayer experience. A single overpowered import can empty a server within a week. Studios know this, which is why the few partnerships that have launched typically use cosmetic items only: a hat, a skin, a banner. Those are portable precisely because they do not matter.
The Incentive Problem
Suppose a studio solves the design issue. There remains a question of motive. Why would a developer spend months integrating items from a game it does not control?
The honest answer, in most cases, is that it would not. Games are businesses built on scarcity and progression. A studio earns when players invest time and money in its own ecosystem. An imported item undermines the progression it is selling. If a player can arrive with a maxed-out character from another title, a studio’s carefully tuned reward loop collapses.
I spoke this month with Devika Aranha, a systems designer who has worked on two live-service titles, and she was blunt. “Every time someone suggests cross-game items in a design meeting, the room goes quiet,” she said. “Because everyone is thinking about their economy, and nobody wants someone else’s inflation in it.”

“Portability is a feature that every studio wants from the others and nobody wants to grant.”
What the Evidence Says
The track record is sparse. Of the several dozen titles that have advertised cross-game assets since 2022, only a small handful support more than one live integration, and in nearly all of them the shared items are cosmetics or collectible badges. No major blockchain game lets a functional weapon, a character level or a land plot carry its full value into a different title.
Players seem to have worked this out. Surveys by community groups suggest that interoperability ranks well below fun, price and friends in the reasons people give for trying a game. The audience that cares most is investors, and they are not the audience that keeps a game alive.
A Better Plan
None of this means ownership has no value. A player who can sell or give away a cosmetic, or prove they were among the first 5,000 to clear a dungeon, gets something real. The mistake is to leap from that modest benefit to a universe of seamless items.
Here is a plan studios could follow instead:
- Build one game that people would play without the token
- Offer ownership where it adds trust, such as tradeable skins and verifiable achievements
- Test portability in a narrow, cosmetic form with one partner before announcing anything broader
- Publish a technical specification for how a partner game would interpret an item, including balance limits
That last point is worth emphasising. A real standard is a document describing rules: which attributes are shared, who adjudicates disputes and what happens when a studio shuts down. Without that, “interoperable” is marketing copy.
The Honest Pitch
There is something refreshing about studios that skip the universe talk. A small team in Tampere that I follow released a puzzle game last month with a plain pitch: your cosmetic unlocks are yours to keep, trade or take elsewhere if another developer chooses to support them. It has had about 60,000 downloads, no token sale and no trailer with a flaming sword.
That is the kind of promise a studio can keep. The bigger one, the sword that works everywhere, requires a level of cooperation that the games industry has never managed in forty years of console wars and platform fights. It will not be delivered by a smart contract. Until someone shows it working across two real games with real stakes, treat the pitch the way you would treat any trailer: as an aspiration, not a feature.
Eli oversees coverage of token markets, derivatives and unlock schedules, after a decade on trading-desk research teams. He is based in Chicago.
Conversation (…)
One briefing. Every morning. Free.
Join readers who start the day with Crypto Beacon: the essential Crypto & web3 stories, curated by our editors.